Difference between revisions of "Giveaway"

From QBWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
fix>QBWikiBot
 
m (ern)
 
(2 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
The '''giveaway''' is the last [[clue]] of a [[tossup]].  Per the rules of [[pyramidality]], it is the easiest clue to buzz on in the tossup. The giveaway almost always comes after the words "For 10 points." Most tournaments hold that 85-90% of teams in the tournament's target skill level should be able to answer the tossup after the giveaway.
+
The '''giveaway''' is the last [[clue]] of a [[tossup]], and thus, per [[pyramidality]], also the easiest clue in the tossup. The giveaway almost always comes after the words "[[For 10 points]]."
  
==Pop culture in giveaways==
+
In modern quizbowl theory, around 90% of the teams in a tournament's [[target audience|target skill level]] should be able to answer a tossup at the end (after the giveaway).
Pop culture clues are unacceptable in giveaways to academic questions.  A tossup on Jethro Tull (the inventor) would contain the giveaway "For 10 points, name this man who invented the seed drill."  It would not mention anything about a progressive rock band or flutes.  If you think that the tossup won't be converted at the desired percentage after the giveaway, write on a different, easier answer.  Do not add a pop culture giveaway to make the question easier.  Teams who get the tossup off of that giveaway will be awarded points in an academic portion of the distribution for buzzing on pop culture knowledge, skewing game results.
 
  
==Other bad giveaways==
+
A giveaway should still be [[internally pyramidal]]. For example, a tossup on Panama should prefer the giveaway {{q|For 10 points, name this Central American country located on a namesake isthmus and host to a namesake canal.}} rather than {{q|For 10 points, a canal over an isthmus crosses what Central American country?}} (assuming that "canal" is the most likely word to be directly associated with Panama and thus the easiest part of the question).
Giveaways can be non-academic while not necessarily being pop culture. For example, a tossup on BF Skinner should not end with a giveaway about how his last name can refer to one who sheds the coats off of animals. Again, points are then awarded for an academic tossup based on non-academic clues, which skews game results.
+
 
 +
==Common types of giveaways==
 +
In literature, giveaways are often the name of the author (when the answerline is a book) or the name of the most well-known book by an author (when the answerline is an author). In geography, a giveaway is often the capital city of a state or country (when the answerline is such).
 +
 
 +
==What to avoid==
 +
Pop culture clues are discouraged in giveaways to academic questions.  A tossup on [[wikipedia:Jethro Tull (agriculturist)|Jethro Tull]] (the inventor) might contain the giveaway {{q|For 10 points, name this man who invented the seed drill.}}  It would not mention anything about the British rock band [[wikipedia:Jethro Tull (band)|Jethro Tull]]. Some people believe that giving teams points off a pop culture giveaway in an academic portion of the distribution for buzzing on pop culture knowledge is unfair. Others believe that question [[conversion]] is more important or support [[mixed impure academic|mixed academic and pop culture questions]]. (See also [[lead-in#Tangential lead-ins|lead-in]].)
 +
 
 +
Giveaways that are [[non-academic]] (but not necessarily pop culture) should be avoided. For example, a tossup on [[wikipedia:B. F. Skinner|B. F. Skinner]] should not end with a giveaway about how his last name can refer to "[[wiktionary:skinner#Noun|one who sheds the coats off of animals]]."
  
 
[[Category:Quizbowl basics]] [[Category:Question-writing philosophies]]
 
[[Category:Quizbowl basics]] [[Category:Question-writing philosophies]]
 
[[Category:Original QBWiki Page]]
 
[[Category:Original QBWiki Page]]

Latest revision as of 02:52, 12 May 2021

The giveaway is the last clue of a tossup, and thus, per pyramidality, also the easiest clue in the tossup. The giveaway almost always comes after the words "For 10 points."

In modern quizbowl theory, around 90% of the teams in a tournament's target skill level should be able to answer a tossup at the end (after the giveaway).

A giveaway should still be internally pyramidal. For example, a tossup on Panama should prefer the giveaway For 10 points, name this Central American country located on a namesake isthmus and host to a namesake canal. rather than For 10 points, a canal over an isthmus crosses what Central American country? (assuming that "canal" is the most likely word to be directly associated with Panama and thus the easiest part of the question).

Common types of giveaways

In literature, giveaways are often the name of the author (when the answerline is a book) or the name of the most well-known book by an author (when the answerline is an author). In geography, a giveaway is often the capital city of a state or country (when the answerline is such).

What to avoid

Pop culture clues are discouraged in giveaways to academic questions. A tossup on Jethro Tull (the inventor) might contain the giveaway For 10 points, name this man who invented the seed drill. It would not mention anything about the British rock band Jethro Tull. Some people believe that giving teams points off a pop culture giveaway in an academic portion of the distribution for buzzing on pop culture knowledge is unfair. Others believe that question conversion is more important or support mixed academic and pop culture questions. (See also lead-in.)

Giveaways that are non-academic (but not necessarily pop culture) should be avoided. For example, a tossup on B. F. Skinner should not end with a giveaway about how his last name can refer to "one who sheds the coats off of animals."