Difference between revisions of "One-person teams"
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Kevin Wang (talk | contribs) |
Kevin Wang (talk | contribs) m (→Criticism) |
||
| (8 intermediate revisions by 2 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | <onlyinclude>A '''one-person team''' (or '''one-man team''') is a [[team]] with multiple [[players]] on it whose fate is perceived to be entirely tied to the scoring abilities of a single player. Literal "one-person" | + | <onlyinclude>A '''one-person team''' (or '''one-man team''') is a [[team]] with multiple [[players]] on it whose fate is perceived to be entirely tied to the scoring abilities of a single player. Literal one-person teams (i.e. those with only a single individual on them) are sometimes called "one-person teams", but are typically referred to as playing [[solo]] instead. |
The term is both laudatory and derisive - while it celebrates the skill of the "one-person" in question, it minimizes the contributions of their teammates (which are often significant) and carries with it the implication that the "one-person" is succeeding in part because of their lack of [[support]]. | The term is both laudatory and derisive - while it celebrates the skill of the "one-person" in question, it minimizes the contributions of their teammates (which are often significant) and carries with it the implication that the "one-person" is succeeding in part because of their lack of [[support]]. | ||
Because of the derogatory connotations, and especially the implied insult to the teammates of the "one-person," it is not a good idea to use this term in reference to any team in your [[tournament]] when you are the [[TD]] or [[moderator]].</onlyinclude> | Because of the derogatory connotations, and especially the implied insult to the teammates of the "one-person," it is not a good idea to use this term in reference to any team in your [[tournament]] when you are the [[TD]] or [[moderator]].</onlyinclude> | ||
| − | |||
One-person teams are frequently successful at the local high school level and occasionally competitive nationally. They are vulnerable against well-balanced attacks from multiple good players at the highest levels of either high school or collegiate quizbowl, which frequently limits their placement. | One-person teams are frequently successful at the local high school level and occasionally competitive nationally. They are vulnerable against well-balanced attacks from multiple good players at the highest levels of either high school or collegiate quizbowl, which frequently limits their placement. | ||
| + | ==Criticism== | ||
| + | The term is a typical example of quizbowlers focusing on the role of individual players in a team; another common example is the prevalence of [[player polls]] and the discussion of individual stats (lately, this has contributed to the [[cult of PPG]]). In all cases, including many one-person teams, all players contribute to the overall success of the team. It is not uncommon for players on a team with a strong [[generalist]] to take on [[specialist]] roles to help ensure maximum [[coverage]]. This sort of division of labor is particularly pronounced on [[bonuses]], in which all players on the team have the opportunity to contribute. | ||
| + | |||
| + | The use of the more common "one-man team" has been criticized as gendered for its implication that such teams are led by men and that women do not contribute to those teams.<ref>[https://hsquizbowl.org/forums/viewtopic.php?p=377483#p377483 Re: Y'all need to pay attention to your own community] by [[Couch's Kingbird]] » Sat Jul 11, 2020 9:25 am</ref> This is one facet of the larger issue that women in quizbowl (and more generally those who are not in the in-group) often have to score points to be considered equals, due to consistent prioritization of top players over those in leadership or administrative roles (which are often pushed onto non-men). | ||
| + | |||
| + | These same power dynamics also affect teams which have scoring asymmetries less extreme than in a one-person team. | ||
| + | <!-- This section is being preserved to simplify the task of creating pages for the members of these teams. It will be deleted afterwards | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==Examples== | ||
===High school=== | ===High school=== | ||
| − | This table is a subset of teams which could be considered "one-player" since 2010, under the loose definition of "a single player | + | This table is a subset of teams which could be considered "one-player" since 2010, under the loose definition of "a single player with prelim PPG is 80% or more of a team's tossup points per game". Entry on this list has been limited to teams that fit this criteria while placing in the top 20 at either [[HSNCT]] or [[NSC]]. |
{| class="wikitable sortable" | {| class="wikitable sortable" | ||
| Line 16: | Line 24: | ||
!NSC | !NSC | ||
|- | |- | ||
| − | {{One-player team row|year=2010|school=[[ | + | {{One-player team row|year=2010|school=[[Alpharetta]]|players=[[Nandhini Sundaresan]], [[Kunal Naik]], [[Gautam Narula]], [[William Horton]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=16|nsc=16th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year=2010|school=[[ | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year=2010|school=[[ | + | {{One-player team row|year=2010|school=[[Detroit Country Day]]|players=[[Michael Dimattia]], [[Neil Gurram]], [[John Bernabei]], [[Chris Schulte]], [[Aamod Dekhne]], [[Kevin Tan]], [[Hannah Cheriyan]]|sortHsnct=7|hsnct=7th|sortNsc=z|nsc=}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year=2010|school=[[ | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year=2010|school=[[ | + | {{One-player team row|year=2010|school=[[Georgetown Day]] A|players=[[Casey Ebner]], [[Matthew Jackson]], [[Oliver Hudson]], [[Daniel Branch-Neufeld]], [[Alex Jiang]]|sortHsnct=5|hsnct=5th|sortNsc=5|nsc=5th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year=2010|school=[[ | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year=2010|school=[[ | + | {{One-player team row|year=2010|school=[[St. Anselm's]]|players=Jacob, Brendan, Aidan, [[Matt Bollinger]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=4|nsc=4th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2010|school=[[St. Ignatius]]|players=[[Jake O'Shea]], [[Amy Brabec]], [[Brian Kenny]], [[Vincent Kenny]], [[Andrew Deveau]], [[Michelle Yuen]]|sortHsnct=43|hsnct=43th|sortNsc=15|nsc=15th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2010|school=[[Torrey Pines]] A|players=[[Chris Wu]], [[Sharad Vikram]], [[Howon Lee]], [[Stephen Liu]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=7|nsc=7th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year=2011|school=[[ | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year=2011|school=[[ | + | {{One-player team row|year=2010|school=[[Walt Whitman]]|players=[[Alex Luta]], [[Douglas Graebner]], [[Oren Steinberg]], [[Jeremy Steinberg]], [[Todd Pollak]], [[Alex Rosen]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=13|nsc=13th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2011|school=[[Alpharetta]]|players=[[Nandhini Sundaresan]], [[Kunal Naik]], [[Gautam Narula]], [[William Horton]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=13|nsc=13th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2011|school=[[Centennial]]|players=[[Katherine Cannella]], [[Nikhil Vallabhaneni]], [[Adam Silverman]], Jenny C. (?)|sortHsnct=5|hsnct=5th|sortNsc=z|nsc=}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year=2012|school=[[ | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2011|school=[[Copley]]|players=[[Jeffrey Wang]], [[Saajid Moyen]], [[Edward Pang]], [[Keval Yerigeri]]|sortHsnct=13|hsnct=13th|sortNsc=z|nsc=}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2011|school=[[Stevenson]]|players=[[Eugene Bulkin]], [[Mark Savin]], [[Kevin Malis]], [[Zach Blumenfeld]], [[Joe Schlude]], [[Collin Shapiro]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=4|nsc=4th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2011|school=[[St. Anselm]]|players=[[Patrick Merkle]], [[Aidan Mehigan]], [[Brendan Ziebarth]], [[Jacob Wasserman]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=19|nsc=19th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2011|school=[[St. Ignatius]]|players=[[Vicky Del Real]], [[Amy Brabec]], [[John Lotus]], [[Josh Mei]], [[DePaul Ohiri]], [[Andrew Deveau]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=8|nsc=8th}} |
| − | + | ||
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2012|school=[[Carbondale]] A|players=[[Michael Steele]], [[Natalie San]], [[Prerak Trivedi]], [[Ben Chametzky]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=5|nsc=5th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2012|school=[[Centennial]]|players=[[Chris Olsen]], [[Claire Garland]], [[Will June]], [[Tyler Knoblett]], [[Adam Silverman]], [[Rick Sheahan]], [[Arun Doogar]], [[Nikhil Vallabhaneni]], [[Elliot Campos]]|sortHsnct=102|hsnct=102th|sortNsc=3|nsc=3rd}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2012|school=[[New Trier]]|players=[[Anne McLaughlin]], [[Michael Goldman]], [[Andrew Wang]], [[Ying Han]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=18|nsc=18th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2012|school=[[St. Anselm's Abbey School]]|players=[[Aidan Mehigan]], [[Jacob Wasserman]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=12|nsc=12th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2012|school=[[Warren G. Harding]]|players=[[Michael Coates]], [[Joseph Angelo]], [[Sam Eartly]], [[Korey Gall]]|sortHsnct=33|hsnct=33th|sortNsc=19|nsc=19th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2013|school=[[Belvidere North]] A|players=[[Conor Reilley]], [[Emily Carrick]], [[Patrick Moore]], [[Dylan Minarik]]|sortHsnct=13|hsnct=13th|sortNsc=19|nsc=19th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2013|school=[[Ladue]]|players=[[Ben Zhang]], [[Haohang Xu]], [[Max Schindler]], [[Jialin Ding]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=1|nsc=1st}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2013|school=[[Northmont]]|players=[[Johnathan Yagisawa]], Helena (?), [[Sam Blizzard]], [[Tori Amos]], [[Meghan Jenkins]], [[Hao Tran]], [[Erin Laing]]|sortHsnct=21|hsnct=21th|sortNsc=19|nsc=19th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2013|school=[[Thomas Jefferson]] A|players=[[Raynor Kuang]], [[Luke Waddell]], [[Nadege Aoki]], [[Sid Verma]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=7|nsc=7th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2014|school=[[Northmont]]|players=[[Helena Jenkins]], [[Meghan Jenkins]], [[Sam Blizzard]], [[Kara Combs]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=7|nsc=7th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | {{One-player team row|year=2014|school=[[St. Joseph]]|players=[[Dan Blackburn]], [[Jack Mehr]], [[Justin Lin]], [[Greg Burton]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=19|nsc=19th}} |
| − | {{One-player team row|year= | + | |
| − | + | {{One-player team row|year=2014|school=[[Western Albemarle]]|players=[[Patrick Andrews]], [[Sam Lesemenn]], [[Tim Dodson]], [[Kelly Missett]], [[Eric Xu]], [[Sam Lesemann]], [[Angela Li]], [[Caroline Koester]]|sortHsnct=8|hsnct=8th|sortNsc=2|nsc=2nd}} | |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | {{One-player team row|year=2015|school=[[Northmont]]|players=[[Lauren Papp]], [[Rachel Tracy]], [[Sam Blizzard]], [[Brendon Jenkins]], [[Kara Combs]]|sortHsnct=13|hsnct=13th|sortNsc=12|nsc=12th}} | |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | {{One-player team row|year=2015|school=[[Rancho Bernardo]]|players=[[Omar El-Sabrout]], [[HoWon Choo]], [[Kion You]], [[Bryan Ugaz]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=19|nsc=19th}} | |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | {{One-player team row|year=2015|school=[[Western Albemarle]]|players=[[Muhannah Hossain]], [[Tim Dodson]], [[Kelly Missett]], [[Eric Xu]], [[Sam Lesemann]], [[Jackson Collins]], [[Caroline Koester]]|sortHsnct=5|hsnct=5th|sortNsc=5|nsc=5th}} | |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | {{One-player team row|year=2016|school=[[Rancho Bernardo]]|players=[[Omar El-Sabrout]], [[Kion You]], [[Howon Choo]], [[Bryan Ugaz]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=15|nsc=15th}} | |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | {{One-player team row|year=2016|school=[[Rockford Auburn]]|players=[[Ethan Strombeck]], [[Cole Timmerwilke]], [[Henry Roe]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=8|nsc=8th}} | |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | {{One-player team row|year=2016|school=[[Westview]]|players=[[Grace Tran]], [[Jennie Wang]], [[Shivank Nayak]], [[Rahul Keyal]], [[Jonathan Tran]], [[Anish Sathe]], [[Kevin Yu]], [[Jordan Lei]]|sortHsnct=53|hsnct=53rd|sortNsc=14|nsc=14th}} | |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | {{One-player team row|year=2017|school=[[Dublin Scioto High School]]|players=[[Clark Smith]], [[Gabriel Pinto]], [[Sanjay Medicherla]], [[Eddy Liu]], [[Enoch Fu]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=6|nsc=6th}} | |
| − | + | ||
| − | + | {{One-player team row|year=2017|school=[[La Jolla]]|players=[[Shane Pauker]], [[James Malouf]], [[Jennifer Andrey]], [[Sam Kaseff]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=8|nsc=8th}} | |
| − | + | ||
| + | {{One-player team row|year=2017|school=[[Lehigh Valley]]|players=[[Lucas Larkin]], [[Jonathan Skee]], [[Alex Schmidt]], [[Ramon Torres]]|sortHsnct=15|hsnct=15th|sortNsc=z|nsc=}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | {{One-player team row|year=2017|school=[[Naperville North]]|players=[[Jacob Fisher]], [[Shawn Yoshida]], [[Emily Hou]], [[Kelvin Li]], [[Jason Hu]], [[Jakob Myers]]|sortHsnct=3|hsnct=3rd|sortNsc=9|nsc=9th}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | {{One-player team row|year=2018|school=[[Battle Ground]]|players=[[Cameron Clark]], [[Max Dambach]], [[Henry Dambach]], [[Jack Lewis]]|sortHsnct=32|hsnct=32nd|sortNsc=16|nsc=16th}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | {{One-player team row|year=2018|school=[[Beavercreek]]|players=[[Abby Cohen]], [[Ziyi Zuo]], [[Hari Parameswaran]], [[David Cohen]]|sortHsnct=5|hsnct=5th|sortNsc=8|nsc=8th}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | {{One-player team row|year=2018|school=[[Crystal Springs Uplands]]|players=[[Partha Rao]], [[Alice Jiang]], [[Justin French]], [[Darren Jian]]|sortHsnct=12|hsnct=12th|sortNsc=7|nsc=7th}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | {{One-player team row|year=2018|school=[[Downingtown STEM]]|players=[[Anish Gadgil]], [[Vishwa Shanmugam]], [[Max Lind]], [[Rohan Vora]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=18|nsc=18th}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | {{One-player team row|year=2018|school=[[Dublin Scioto]]|players=[[Gabriel Pinto]], [[Clark Smith]], [[Visvam Srinivasan]], [[Edward Liu]]|sortHsnct=z|hsnct=|sortNsc=2|nsc=2nd}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | {{One-player team row|year=2018|school=[[Lehigh Valley]]|players=[[Nathaniel Schmidt]], [[Alex Schmidt]]|sortHsnct=12|hsnct=12th|sortNsc=21|nsc=21st}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | {{One-player team row|year=2018|school=[[Miami Valley]]|players=[[William Groger]], [[John John Groger]]|sortHsnct=20|hsnct=20th|sortNsc=34|nsc=34th}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | {{One-player team row|year=2019|school=[[Beavercreek]]|players=[[Abby Cohen]], [[Tiffany Zhou]], [[Hari Parameswaran]], [[Tegan Kapadia]]|sortHsnct=1|hsnct=1st|sortNsc=7|nsc=7th}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | {{One-player team row|year=2019|school=[[James E. Taylor]]|players=[[William Golden]], [[Jed Wang]], [[Katie Sturzu]], [[Mitchell Shadden]]|sortHsnct=5|hsnct=5th|sortNsc=2|nsc=2nd}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | {{One-player team row|year=2019|school=[[Georgetown Day]]|players=[[Avani Ahuja]], [[Matthew Siff]], [[Arthur Delot-Vilain]], [[Nathaniel Rosenberg]], [[Alex Moon]]|sortHsnct=31|hsnct=31st|sortNsc=17|nsc=17th}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | {{One-player team row|year=2019|school=[[Rockford Auburn]]|players=[[Ethan Strombeck]], [[Justin Abel]], [[Leif Verace]], [[Lilly Chávez]]|sortHsnct=8|hsnct=8th|sortNsc=6th|nsc=6th}} | ||
| + | |||
| + | {{One-player team row|year=2021|school=[[Lambert]]|players=[[Anish Kayarthodi]], [[Aadi Karthik]], [[Justin Kim]], [[Vishal Sareddy]], [[Arjun Birthi]], [[Adi Krish]]|sortHsnct=19|hsnct=19th|sortNsc=9|nsc=9th}} | ||
|} | |} | ||
===College=== | ===College=== | ||
| + | --> | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==References== | ||
| + | <references/> | ||
[[Category: Quizbowl lingo]] | [[Category: Quizbowl lingo]] | ||
[[Category:Original QBWiki Page]] | [[Category:Original QBWiki Page]] | ||
Latest revision as of 19:22, 18 September 2022
A one-person team (or one-man team) is a team with multiple players on it whose fate is perceived to be entirely tied to the scoring abilities of a single player. Literal one-person teams (i.e. those with only a single individual on them) are sometimes called "one-person teams", but are typically referred to as playing solo instead.
The term is both laudatory and derisive - while it celebrates the skill of the "one-person" in question, it minimizes the contributions of their teammates (which are often significant) and carries with it the implication that the "one-person" is succeeding in part because of their lack of support. Because of the derogatory connotations, and especially the implied insult to the teammates of the "one-person," it is not a good idea to use this term in reference to any team in your tournament when you are the TD or moderator.
One-person teams are frequently successful at the local high school level and occasionally competitive nationally. They are vulnerable against well-balanced attacks from multiple good players at the highest levels of either high school or collegiate quizbowl, which frequently limits their placement.
Criticism
The term is a typical example of quizbowlers focusing on the role of individual players in a team; another common example is the prevalence of player polls and the discussion of individual stats (lately, this has contributed to the cult of PPG). In all cases, including many one-person teams, all players contribute to the overall success of the team. It is not uncommon for players on a team with a strong generalist to take on specialist roles to help ensure maximum coverage. This sort of division of labor is particularly pronounced on bonuses, in which all players on the team have the opportunity to contribute.
The use of the more common "one-man team" has been criticized as gendered for its implication that such teams are led by men and that women do not contribute to those teams.[1] This is one facet of the larger issue that women in quizbowl (and more generally those who are not in the in-group) often have to score points to be considered equals, due to consistent prioritization of top players over those in leadership or administrative roles (which are often pushed onto non-men).
These same power dynamics also affect teams which have scoring asymmetries less extreme than in a one-person team.
References
- ↑ Re: Y'all need to pay attention to your own community by Couch's Kingbird » Sat Jul 11, 2020 9:25 am