Difference between revisions of "Collegiate difficulties"

From QBWiki
Jump to navigation Jump to search
(list cites 4 examples)
 
(20 intermediate revisions by 4 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
−
''See also: [[Difficulty]]''
+
{{Collegiate difficulties}}
 +
:''See also: [[Difficulty]]''
 +
'''Collegiate quizbowl tournaments''' span a wide range of '''difficulty levels''', from the easiest difficulties intended for college students who are complete beginners to quizbowl (which overlap with the difficulties of high school quizbowl), to the hardest difficulties intended to challenge college students, college graduates, and seasoned players at national championships, [[open|open tournament]]s, and beyond.
  
−
The following is an (incomplete) list of commonly-used collegiate tournament difficulties, in order from easiest to hardest.
+
The terminology for collegiate difficulties can be ambiguous, competing, or ill-defined. This page attempts to explain commonly-used collegiate tournament difficulties.
  
 
==Terminology==
 
==Terminology==
  
−
There are four broad categories of college difficulty: '''[[novice]]''', '''[[Regular difficulty|regular]]''', '''[[nationals]]''', and '''post-nationals'''.
+
There are five broad categories of college difficulty: '''[[novice]]''', '''medium''', '''[[Regular difficulty|regular]]''', '''[[nationals]]''', and '''post-nationals'''.
  
−
The first three correspond roughly to [[ACF Fall]], [[ACF Regionals]], and [[ACF Nationals]] respectively. In turn, ACF Regionals difficulty corresponds to DI [[SCT]] and ACF Nationals to DI [[ICT]]; there is no exact [[NAQT]] equivalent to ACF Fall, though DII [[SCT]] is similar. Each of these pairs of ACF and NAQT tournaments are roughly interchangable. The fourth "post-nationals" difficulty designates any tournament harder than ACF Nationals, of which [[Chicago Open]] is the prototypical example.
+
The first four correspond roughly to [[ACF Fall]], [[ACF Winter]], [[ACF Regionals]], and [[ACF Nationals]] respectively. In turn, ACF Regionals difficulty corresponds to DI [[SCT]] and ACF Nationals to DI [[ICT]]; there is no exact [[NAQT]] equivalent to ACF Fall, though DII [[SCT]] is similar. Each of these pairs of ACF and NAQT tournaments are roughly interchangeable. The fifth "post-nationals" difficulty designates any tournament harder than ACF Nationals, of which [[Chicago Open]] is the prototypical example.
  
−
====Plus and Minus====
+
===="Plus" and "Minus"====
  
−
Sets that aim to be easier or harder than an existing set or difficulty are typically denoted "plus" or "minus". For example, a set trying to be more difficult than ACF Regionals might call itself "Regionals-plus" or "regular-plus."
+
Tournaments that aim to be easier or harder than a reference difficulty level can be denoted by appending "plus" or "minus" to the reference difficulty level. For example, a tournament that aims to be more difficult than ACF Regionals might be called "Regionals-plus" or "[[regular-plus]]."
  
−
====Regular vs. Regionals====
+
===="Regular" vs. "Regionals"====
 +
:''See also: [[Regular difficulty#Redefining regular]]''
 +
Some people define "regular" difficulty as the same difficulty of ACF Regionals. However, regular typically refers to a wider range of difficulties and includes a number of easier ("medium") tournaments. This distinction between the "regular" and "Regionals" difficulties has been pushed further by arguments to have ACF Regionals no longer represent the difficulty of the median tournament, e.g. by lowering the difficulty of other tournaments relative to Regionals or by making Regionals itself easier.
  
−
Theoretically, "regular" difficulty and "Regionals" difficulty are the exact same, as regular difficulty is defined as the difficulty of ACF Regionals. However, regular typically refers to a wider range of difficulties and includes a number of easier tournaments. This distinction between the "regular" and "Regionals" difficulties has been pushed further by arguments to have ACF Regionals no longer represent the difficulty of the median tournament, e.g. by lowering the difficulty of other tournaments relative to Regionals or by making Regionals itself easier.
+
Advocates for lowering the average difficulty of college quizbowl to be roughly the difficulty of 2018 [[EFT]] may sometimes use "regular" difficulty to refer to this new difficulty, with "Regionals" difficulty then being harder than "regular". For clarification purposes, this wiki refers to this difficulty level as "medium."
  
−
Advocates for lowering the average difficulty of college quizbowl to be roughly the difficulty of 2018 [[EFT]] have used "regular" difficulty to refer to this new difficulty - "Regionals" difficulty would then represent the unchanged objective difficulty of ACF Regionals, which would now be harder than "regular".
+
====College Quizbowl Calendar Scale====
 +
As part of his work to improve tournament scheduling, cooperation, and knowledge sharing in quizbowl, [[Ophir Lifshitz]] developed the [https://collegequizbowlcalendar.com/difficulty-scale/ college quizbowl calendar difficulty scale] in March 2018 to remove much of the ambiguity associated with the previously mentioned terms and to better communicate the difficulty of the tournaments being listed side-by-side on the [[College Quizbowl Calendar]]. The scale uses four broad ordinal categories, spanning from one to four "dots", to cover the range of difficulties of mainstream college quizbowl tournaments, with two principal relative thresholds ("too easy for experts" and "too hard for beginners") defining 2 and 3 dots. Thus, it is not recommended for question sets to target fine-grained difficulty levels (or "half-dots") in between each of these categories.
  
−
====College Quizbowl Calendar Scale====
+
[[Image:Difficulty dots.png]]
−
As part of his work with improving tournament scheduling, [[Ophir Lifshitz]] has developed the [https://collegequizbowlcalendar.com/difficulty-scale/ college quizbowl calendar difficulty scale] to remove much of the ambiguity associated with the previously mentioned terms. There are between one and four dots which span the range of difficulties from novice to nationals. There are also half-dots in between each of these categories, but these are not recommended for use.
 
  
 
==The List==
 
==The List==
Line 27: Line 31:
 
**1 dot on the college quizbowl calendar difficulty scale
 
**1 dot on the college quizbowl calendar difficulty scale
 
*regular-minus - [[MUT]], [[ILLIAC]], [[SMT]] - typically considered the step above novice
 
*regular-minus - [[MUT]], [[ILLIAC]], [[SMT]] - typically considered the step above novice
−
**"1.5 dots" - by convention, the college quizbowl calendar scale does not recommend half-dot increments
+
**"1.5 dots"<sup>†</sup>
 
*"regular"
 
*"regular"
 
**2 dots on the college quizbowl calendar difficulty scale
 
**2 dots on the college quizbowl calendar difficulty scale
 
***[[EFT]] - the difficulty of the revived set under the head-editorship of [[Will Alston]]
 
***[[EFT]] - the difficulty of the revived set under the head-editorship of [[Will Alston]]
−
**2.5 dots
+
***[[ACF Winter]]
 +
**"2.5 dots"<sup>†</sup>
 +
****[[IKEA]] and [[ARCADIA]]
 
**3 dots
 
**3 dots
 
***Regionals - [[ACF Regionals]]
 
***Regionals - [[ACF Regionals]]
−
*Regionals-plus - 2015 [[VCU Open]]
+
*[[Regionals-plus]] - 2015 [[VCU Open]]
 
*[[Nationals-minus]] - the difficulty of typical Spring Open tournaments
 
*[[Nationals-minus]] - the difficulty of typical Spring Open tournaments
 
**overlaps with upper end of Regionals-plus
 
**overlaps with upper end of Regionals-plus
 
**[[Minnesota Open]] - used to ground [[Cane Ridge Revival]] and [[George Oppen]]
 
**[[Minnesota Open]] - used to ground [[Cane Ridge Revival]] and [[George Oppen]]
−
**3.5 dots
+
**"3.5 dots"<sup>†</sup>
 
*Nationals - [[ACF Nationals]], [[ICT]]
 
*Nationals - [[ACF Nationals]], [[ICT]]
 
**4 dots
 
**4 dots
Line 45: Line 51:
 
**[[2017 Chicago Open]]
 
**[[2017 Chicago Open]]
 
**[[Arrabal]]
 
**[[Arrabal]]
 +
 +
<sup>†</sup>: by convention, the college quizbowl calendar scale does not recommend half-dot increments
 +
 +
[[Category: Difficulty and quality scales for packet sets]]
 +
{{c|Lists}}

Latest revision as of 16:12, 29 July 2022

College is Hard
See also: Difficulty

Collegiate quizbowl tournaments span a wide range of difficulty levels, from the easiest difficulties intended for college students who are complete beginners to quizbowl (which overlap with the difficulties of high school quizbowl), to the hardest difficulties intended to challenge college students, college graduates, and seasoned players at national championships, open tournaments, and beyond.

The terminology for collegiate difficulties can be ambiguous, competing, or ill-defined. This page attempts to explain commonly-used collegiate tournament difficulties.

Terminology

There are five broad categories of college difficulty: novice, medium, regular, nationals, and post-nationals.

The first four correspond roughly to ACF Fall, ACF Winter, ACF Regionals, and ACF Nationals respectively. In turn, ACF Regionals difficulty corresponds to DI SCT and ACF Nationals to DI ICT; there is no exact NAQT equivalent to ACF Fall, though DII SCT is similar. Each of these pairs of ACF and NAQT tournaments are roughly interchangeable. The fifth "post-nationals" difficulty designates any tournament harder than ACF Nationals, of which Chicago Open is the prototypical example.

"Plus" and "Minus"

Tournaments that aim to be easier or harder than a reference difficulty level can be denoted by appending "plus" or "minus" to the reference difficulty level. For example, a tournament that aims to be more difficult than ACF Regionals might be called "Regionals-plus" or "regular-plus."

"Regular" vs. "Regionals"

See also: Regular difficulty#Redefining regular

Some people define "regular" difficulty as the same difficulty of ACF Regionals. However, regular typically refers to a wider range of difficulties and includes a number of easier ("medium") tournaments. This distinction between the "regular" and "Regionals" difficulties has been pushed further by arguments to have ACF Regionals no longer represent the difficulty of the median tournament, e.g. by lowering the difficulty of other tournaments relative to Regionals or by making Regionals itself easier.

Advocates for lowering the average difficulty of college quizbowl to be roughly the difficulty of 2018 EFT may sometimes use "regular" difficulty to refer to this new difficulty, with "Regionals" difficulty then being harder than "regular". For clarification purposes, this wiki refers to this difficulty level as "medium."

College Quizbowl Calendar Scale

As part of his work to improve tournament scheduling, cooperation, and knowledge sharing in quizbowl, Ophir Lifshitz developed the college quizbowl calendar difficulty scale in March 2018 to remove much of the ambiguity associated with the previously mentioned terms and to better communicate the difficulty of the tournaments being listed side-by-side on the College Quizbowl Calendar. The scale uses four broad ordinal categories, spanning from one to four "dots", to cover the range of difficulties of mainstream college quizbowl tournaments, with two principal relative thresholds ("too easy for experts" and "too hard for beginners") defining 2 and 3 dots. Thus, it is not recommended for question sets to target fine-grained difficulty levels (or "half-dots") in between each of these categories.

Difficulty dots.png

The List

†: by convention, the college quizbowl calendar scale does not recommend half-dot increments

Retrieved from "https://www.qbwiki.com/w/index.php?title=Collegiate_difficulties&oldid=57386"