Difference between revisions of "Geography"
Chris Chiego (talk | contribs) |
m (→Distribution) |
||
| (16 intermediate revisions by 3 users not shown) | |||
| Line 1: | Line 1: | ||
| − | Geography questions appear in most quizbowl tournaments. They may be on physical or cultural geography | + | {{Category box}} |
| + | <onlyinclude> | ||
| + | '''Geography''' questions appear in most quizbowl tournaments. They may be on physical or cultural geography topics—most tournaments will strive for a balance of both.</onlyinclude> | ||
| + | |||
| + | ==Distribution== | ||
| + | [[NAQT]] [[IS]]-sets and the [[HSNCT]] have approximately 1.9/1.9 geography per 24/24 round [http://www.naqt.com/hs/distribution.jsp] [http://www.naqt.com/hsnct/distribution.jsp]; their [[Division I]] collegiate packets have about 1.2/1.2 on average per round out of 26/26 [http://www.naqt.com/college/distribution.jsp]. In contrast, [[ACF]] packets require only .5/.5 geography in a submitted packet of 24/24 (which is then cut to 20/20) [https://acf-quizbowl.com/distribution/]; most [[mACF]] sets have a similar amount, though some high school sets have 1/1. | ||
| + | |||
| + | Some geography content inevitably appears outside its designated category, given the relevance of geographical locations to history, literature, etc. | ||
==Debate== | ==Debate== | ||
| − | A long-running debate in quizbowl exists over whether to reduce or eliminate geography questions from the distribution of some | + | A long-running debate in quizbowl exists over whether to reduce or eliminate geography questions from the distribution of some tournaments, particularly higher level college events such as [[ACF Nationals]] [http://hsquizbowl.org/forums/viewtopic.php?f=21&t=8589&p=152043]. Opponents of geography questions often cite them for being uninteresting, full of unlearnable information beyond the basics, or fundamentally difficult to write as anything but a list of "[[almanac clues]]" of little importance. Supporters note that geography is knowable and known, and can be written to use information about interesting and famous places that affect/have affected the world. |
| − | Over time in part due to this debate, there has been a shift from the use of said [[Quizbowl_lingo#almanac_clue|almanac clues]] to a more diverse range of | + | Over time in part due to this debate, there has been a shift away from the use of said [[Quizbowl_lingo#almanac_clue|almanac clues]] in geography questions and to a more diverse range of clues including music, food, traditions, and the interactions between human and physical geography. |
| − | |||
| − | |||
| − | |||
==Notable Players== | ==Notable Players== | ||
Notable geography [[specialist]]s in quizbowl do exist, contrary to the anti-geography crowd's insistence; such specialists have included [[Jeff Hoppes]], [[Kyle Haddad-Fonda]], [[Dallas Simons]], and [[Raynell Cooper]]. | Notable geography [[specialist]]s in quizbowl do exist, contrary to the anti-geography crowd's insistence; such specialists have included [[Jeff Hoppes]], [[Kyle Haddad-Fonda]], [[Dallas Simons]], and [[Raynell Cooper]]. | ||
| − | See also: [[Geography Monstrosity]], a | + | ==See also:== |
| + | *[[Geography Monstrosity]], a roughly annual [[subject tournament]] of geography questions | ||
[[Category:Subjects]] | [[Category:Subjects]] | ||
Latest revision as of 14:46, 21 November 2021
Geography questions appear in most quizbowl tournaments. They may be on physical or cultural geography topics—most tournaments will strive for a balance of both.
Distribution
NAQT IS-sets and the HSNCT have approximately 1.9/1.9 geography per 24/24 round [1] [2]; their Division I collegiate packets have about 1.2/1.2 on average per round out of 26/26 [3]. In contrast, ACF packets require only .5/.5 geography in a submitted packet of 24/24 (which is then cut to 20/20) [4]; most mACF sets have a similar amount, though some high school sets have 1/1.
Some geography content inevitably appears outside its designated category, given the relevance of geographical locations to history, literature, etc.
Debate
A long-running debate in quizbowl exists over whether to reduce or eliminate geography questions from the distribution of some tournaments, particularly higher level college events such as ACF Nationals [5]. Opponents of geography questions often cite them for being uninteresting, full of unlearnable information beyond the basics, or fundamentally difficult to write as anything but a list of "almanac clues" of little importance. Supporters note that geography is knowable and known, and can be written to use information about interesting and famous places that affect/have affected the world.
Over time in part due to this debate, there has been a shift away from the use of said almanac clues in geography questions and to a more diverse range of clues including music, food, traditions, and the interactions between human and physical geography.
Notable Players
Notable geography specialists in quizbowl do exist, contrary to the anti-geography crowd's insistence; such specialists have included Jeff Hoppes, Kyle Haddad-Fonda, Dallas Simons, and Raynell Cooper.
See also:
- Geography Monstrosity, a roughly annual subject tournament of geography questions