Non-Definitive Greatest Players Lists
Besides the Definitive Greatest Players List there have been other attempts to establish a list of the greatest players of all-time.
Adam Fine's List
A list of the top 100 players ever from 1998 as compiled by Adam Fine.
100. Shawn Pickrell
98. Adam Humphreys (SC)
97. Brad Harris
96. Emily Moore (OK)
95. Shawn Askew
94. Mark Coen
93. Dom Ricci
92. Alan Taber (Stan)
91. Steve Schroeder (Vandy)
90. Mike Zarren
89. Willie Keller
88. Julie Stahlhut
87. Ed Cohn
86. Fred Bush
85. Vishnu Jejjala
84. Ken LaSala
83. Bobby Shepard
82. Karl Schmidt
81. Ken ?? (BYU)
80. Richard Mason (CalTech)
79. Rachel Marshak
78. Andy Zimdars (CMU)
77. Bronson Messer
76. Jeff Newman
75. Jen Wadsack
74. David Levinson
73. Jeff Boulier
72. Tim Young
71. Dave Vacca
70. Hormuzd Katki
69. Steve Wang
68. Phil O'Donoghue
67. Dwight Kidder
66. Mark Staloff
65. John Harris
64. Greg Sorenson (trash)
63. Pat Friel
62. Carol Herin-J
61. Nick Meyer (Berk)
60. Matt Baker
59. Chris Goheen
58. Lorin Burte
57. Alex Mouat
56. Jeff Stewart
55. Ravin Garg
54. Long Nguyen
53. Pat Matthews
52. John Edwards
50. T.C. Ford
49. James Rogers
48. John Nam
46. Rory Molinari
45. Laura Cleveland (ex-NCSU)
44. Larry Sorrels
43. Haggai Elitzur
42. Guy Jordan
41. Matt Colvin
40. Phil Huang
39. Christine Moritz
38. Dan Fuller
37. Steve Lin
36. Tom Drucker
35. Rick Grimes
34. Benoy Chacko
33. David Frazee
32. Patrick Brannon
31. Brian Rostron
30. Julie Singer
29. Jim Bales
28. Eric Hillemann
27. Adam Kemezis
26. Dave Goodman
24. Eric Bell
23. Jason Hong
22. Robert Trent
21. James Anderson
20. Arthur Fleming
19. Jesse Molesworth
18. Victor Rosenberg
17. Roger Lee
16. Dave Hamilton
15. Marc Swisdak
14. Mike Musgrove
12. Eric Tentarelli
11. Jon Saluta
10. Robert Margolis
8. Jason King
7. John Sheahan
5. Jeff Johnson
4. Jim Dendy
3. Andrew Yaphe
2. Don Windham
1. Tom Waters
Larry Horse's Retort
As a response to the previous list, a poster claiming to be Chicago player Pericles Abbasi compiled his own list of top players.
20 ... That angry kid from Rochester
19 ... That bearded loser who is also from Rochester
18 ... That guy from Berkeley who talks too loudly
17 ... That fat guy from -- I forget where he was from. You know, the fat one
16 ... That guy from Harvard who's wrong a lot
15 ... That girl from -- oh wait, I must have the wrong board. Won't be no girls in this top 20, yo. So make it that guy from Texas A&M with the ears
14 ... That guy from Illinois who thinks he's good or something
13 ... That guy from Michigan who gets real surly
12 ... That other guy from Illinois who actually is kind of good
11 ... That big lovable bear of a man from Yale
10 ... The crunkest man in tha game, Chicago's own Seth Teitler
9 ... That guy from Berkeley who cries about science questions
8 ... That other guy from Berkeley who keeps his mouth shut most of the time
7 ... That guy from Michigan with the hats and the floppy hair
6 ... Dwight Kidder
5 ... That guy from Princeton who's supposed to be angry but mostly looks like his puppy just died. Oh that's you Mr. Frankel
4 ... That old guy from Chicago who made R. cry
3 ... That other guy from Michigan who's got his shit together
2 ... That other old guy from Chicago. You know, the Indian one
1 ... The sexiest man in the game. You know who I'm talking about -- his name rhymes with "Fat Wiener"
Frankel's Attempt
Following the locking of the previous thread because of Larry Horse's spamming, Chris Frankel himself attempted creating a list, viewable here and reproduced below.
1. Andrew Yaphe
---
---
4. Adam Kemezis
---
5. Matt Weiner
---
6. Matt Lafer
7. Mike Sorice
8. Jeff Hoppes
9. Seth Teitler
10. Jerry Vinokurov
11. Chris Romero
12. Chris Frankel
---
13. Mike Wehrman
999999999. Leo Wolpert (OK, I'd actually put him closer to #14, but he's still horrible at QB)
15. Seth Kendall
16. Robert Beard
17. Dan Suzman
18. Fred Bush
19. Micha Elsner
20. Sudheer Potru