Experimental Rule -- Yay or Nay

The rule which I wish to discuss here is purely
hypothetical, but if enough people say sure why not, then we'll
include it. The rule is officially dubbed "The You Don't
Know Jack Opponent Forcing Buzz Rule" because rules
look more impressive if they have long titles. But for
everyone's sake we'll call it the Screw Rule.

Before
each match, everyone will receive one (1) screw (or,
more likely, a picture of a screw). These do not carry
over into the next round.

To use it, you must
buzz in while the question is still being read and
clearly say "I will screw [x]", where [x] is your unlucky
opponent. To prevent the obvious strategy (the one-word
screw), the screwee will hear the question either to the
point of buzz or to the power mark, whichever is
later.

If the screwee is incorrect, it will be treated as
if they had buzzed in and gotten it wrong. The
screwer will still have his/her buzz for that question.
However, should the screwee actually get it right, not
only will he/she receive 10 or 15 points (whatever is
appropriate), but the screwer will be assessed a 5 point
penalty.

There is only one obvious drawback I can see here: the
person is screwed before the power mark, and upon
hearing the power part of the question, is the only one
in the room who doesn't realize the answer. So we
have a buzzer race on the power mark. However, I will
attempt to place the power in the correct location so
that this is not possible (between a person's two
names ideally, but also immediately before the key word
in the middle of the question).

So, email me
at apg_at_... and let me know where you stand on
this:

(a) Use it for the entire tournament.
(b) Use it
only for the rounds with 3 or more people.
(c) Do
not use it at all.

Andy

This archive was generated by hypermail 2.4.0: Sat 12 Feb 2022 12:30:44 AM EST EST